Amazon.com Widgets

 

Michael Healy

Celebration for the Religious and the Secular Man

Dec. 26 at 1:04pm

The experience of life, of death, of time, of celebration—e.g., Christmas—is decidedly different for the religious man compared to the secular man.  Mircea Eliade, in his book The Sacred and the Profane, offers four points of difference here (pp. 202-206).

            The religious man believes that there is an absolute reality, the sacred, transcending but manifesting itself in this world and making it real.  Second, he not only believes that life has a sacred origin but also that persons can only be fulfilled to the extent that they are genuinely religious, i.e., in contact with the sacred.  Third, he believes that the history of this world and of his own life involves the history of God’s creative and providential action. Fourthly, he believes that he is called to reactualize sacred  history, to imitate the divine behavior, in order to keep himself close to the divine.

            In contrast, the secular man distances himself from and opposes each of these fundamental attitudes.  First, he refuses transcendence, thereby “leveling” reality and making all things relative, without anchor.  Second, he regards himself as the sole actor in history; he makes himself, without any model outside the human condition. Thus he experiences the idea of the transcendent and the sacred as a threat and an obstacle to his power and freedom.  He must then desacralize himself and the world completely in order to preserve his autonomy.  Third, therefore, secular man has a bit of the sadness of tragedy about him; he is formed only by opposing his own heritage.  He must attempt to empty himself of all religion and trans-human meaning which has come down to him in his tradition.  He must define himself in this negative way.  And yet, fourth, this means that he cannot help preserving some vestiges of the behavior of religious man—now emptied of religious meaning.  As Eliade says, “He forms himself by a series of denials and refusals, but he continues to be haunted by the realities that he has refused and denied.”

            Thus the secular man may still “celebrate” Christmas, New Year’s, a marriage, a birth, etc., but emptied of the real meaning behind them.  Again, as Eliade says, “Strictly speaking, the great majority of irreligious men are not liberated from religious behavior, from theologies and mythologies.  They sometimes stagger under a whole magico-religious paraphernalia, which, however, has degenerated to the point of caricature and hence is hard to recognize it for what it is.”

            This is what I am reminded of when I see a million people gathered in Times Square for New Year’s, or when I see a predominance of “Christmas” decorations in the mode of snowmen, Charlie Brown characters, reindeer, polar bears, chipmunks, etc., etc. The joyful, celebratory aspect is implied in all this, but the reason why is lost and obscured.  The simple manger scene tells the real story.


 

Katie van Schaijik

I've only just not gotten to reading this post.  I endorse it with all my heart.  

Strictly speaking, the great majority of irreligious men are not liberated from religious behavior, from theologies and mythologies. 

I read somewhere not long ago that studies show that agnostics and atheists are much more likely to believe in things like space aliens and paranormal phenomena than religious people. The ineradicable religious impulse in the human person needs an Object.  If it rejects the Absolute, it will absolutize something contingent.

This is what I am reminded of when I see a million people gathered in Times Square for New Year’s, or when I see a predominance of “Christmas” decorations in the mode of snowmen, Charlie Brown characters, reindeer, polar bears, chipmunks, etc., etc. The joyful, celebratory aspect is implied in all this, but the reason why is lost and obscured.

I have similar thoughts hearing pop "Christmas music".  "All I want for Christmas is you."  The pathetic reduction in meaning and beauty is distressing.

#1 - Dec. 30 at 10:41am | quote

Michael Healy

True, but Elvis' "Blue Christmas" is still a classic!  (At least it spoke to my adolescent heart again and again!)

#2 - Dec. 30 at 2:24pm | quote

 

To comment, please sign in or register first. (It's free and easy, and helps us prevent spam.)

 

Stay informed

Reading circles

Lectures

Latest comments

  • Re: The Gift of Joy
  • By: Marie Meaney
  • Re: The Gift of Joy
  • By: Rhett Segall
  • Re: Protagoras and Me
  • By: Sapperdepitjes
  • Re: A memoir of spiritual abuse and recovery
  • By: M. C.
  • Re: A memoir of spiritual abuse and recovery
  • By: Katie van Schaijik
  • Re: A memoir of spiritual abuse and recovery
  • By: M. C.
  • Re: The Gift of Joy
  • By: Marie Meaney
  • Re: The Gift of Joy
  • By: Katie van Schaijik
  • Re: A memoir of spiritual abuse and recovery
  • By: Katie van Schaijik
  • Re: A memoir of spiritual abuse and recovery
  • By: M. C.

Latest active posts